Episodes Blog About Shop
Subscribe

Mythbusting: Herbal Teas

.

Comments

Jean-Loup | 2008-12-03 14:04:39 UTC

My experience of Camomille tea is that it definitely works as a relaxant providing you don’t drink it while in a stressful situation.

For instance it’s quite good if you’ve had a hard day at work, uni or whatever and just need something to lighten up.

At then end of the day it’s not harmful so even it’s only psychosomatic effects, it can’t hurt to drink it. ;)

Sophie | 2008-12-03 15:56:19 UTC

The truth is these herbs do work, just not very potently in the form of a teabag. This is because there is hardly any herb in the bag, just fairly old powdered leaf scrapings. It’s best to use the real plant instead!

Dougal Stanton | 2008-12-03 16:15:49 UTC

(Commenting without watching the whole video, cos my computer’s being uncooperative at video playback at the moment.)

I totally agree with the initial belief that all you’re getting is “a good cup of tea”. And then if it turns out you don’t like the taste of camomile/whatever, you’re not even getting that.

Personally, I recommend a mug of hot chocolate with half a shot of dark rum in it if you want to relax. Also a DVD and a blanket.

Sabrosa | 2008-12-03 16:19:47 UTC

Awww Alex, dear me! Please tell me you drink coffee and white tea? They’re ‘erbs aren’t they?

They make soap out of cammomile so at least you’ll be nice and clean inside.

Hugh | 2008-12-03 16:19:50 UTC

Sophie – that’s really interesting. Any tips for where to find the plants?

Jean-Loup – that’s about my experience with Camomile too. But I’m sure Alex will be on later to disagree!

Dougal – it has to be said, some of the teas taste really nice. Ginkgo is lovely, and I’m a fan of peppermint personally – although that really does have some medical effects, so I have to be a bit careful with it!

Alex | 2008-12-03 16:58:41 UTC

Jean-Loup – Is a relaxant which doesn’t work when you’re stressed really a relaxant? I think Chamomile’s entirely psycho-somatic, but I suppose there’s nothing inherently wrong with psycho-sematic stuff.

Sophie – Perhaps. That was kinda the point of the test; to see if the huge amounts of tea yeilded any effect. I’m wasn’t out and out saying that herbs don’t have any effect, that’d just be stupid. I was just saying that I think that most of the ones supposed to have effects in herbal teas don’t.

Dougal – Whoa, someone agrees! Thanks, thought I might have a bit of a hard time with this one.

Sabrosa – Yeah, I drink coffee and tea, and can say for a fact that it works. I just didn’t reckon that any of these herbal teas with supposed “medicinal” effects did anything useful or interesting. Gotta admit that the Valerian worked though.

pajh | 2008-12-03 22:44:43 UTC

I use camomile and valerian a lot. I find that camomile is pretty good for settling the stomach—-but ginger is better for that. It only seems to work as a relaxant if you can’t get hold of any valerian.

CAIN | 2008-12-04 00:43:17 UTC

Another great installment – my favorite so far, actually, given how many times I laughed out loud.

And I agree about the effectiveness of valerian – I’ve used the root for years to help me sleep, both in pill and liquid extract forms. It’s good stuff, especially when taken about an hour before bedtime.

Pipesdreams | 2008-12-04 07:09:37 UTC

@pajh Couldn’t agree more with your ginger vs. chamomile comment. Tastier and more effective.

Valerian is soothing, but for a truly impenetrable blanket of mellow relaxation, I’d have to argue that St. John’s Wort tea by Yogi Teas is the absolute best.

You could play hours of Halo with me on your team, watching me clumsily fall off of ramparts or accidentally getting stuck in a corner then mashing the pad frantically and blowing myself up with a grenade, ruining our team’s chances of glory by escalating our death count with my mindless, frustrating, totally unintentional game suicides, and yet still maintain a facade of perfect calm.

The only problem is, I don’t know if you can get the stuff in the UK; I think it might be illegal in Ireland, as it reacts poorly with pharmaceutical antidepressants, and it has a nasty reputation for undermining the good work done by birth control, which for ladies trying to have consequence-free pre-marital sex, really counteracts the whole “stress free” aspect of the tea.

Anyhow, if you’re not on Prozac or the pill, I recommend.

pajh | 2008-12-04 15:33:15 UTC

@Pipesdreams: St. John’s wort is pretty easy to get over here. I have a blend of my own that includes some. You’re right that it interferes with the contraceptive pill, but fortunately this isn’t a problem for me.

Saev | 2008-12-04 15:47:54 UTC

Something to keep in mind is the weight to consumption ration. The average Chinese person is very small and weighs about as much as a large grapefruit.

The other thing to consider is something Sophie hinted at. How much of the herb is in the tea bag, as well as does the potency rise or fall during the drying process. Some herbs are more potent dried, others not so much.

Anyways, wowinsider.com linked to this due to the wow reference so this is the first time seeing you guys, but as someone working to get their masters in food science at the end of the year… very very wicked!

Julian | 2008-12-04 23:32:16 UTC

Awesome one guys, my second favourite episode, awesome :)

Jeremiah Blatz | 2008-12-05 00:16:32 UTC

Double-blind?

Give one person chamomile, another ginko, and a third valerian, see how their scores change.

If you’re feeling extra-cool, get one of those biofeedback thingees and repeat.

pajh | 2008-12-05 00:53:12 UTC

Too many individual differences, surely? If I mainlined cocaine and we gave Alex chloroform, he’d still be better at Guitar Hero than me. I suck at games.

Leah | 2008-12-05 01:16:04 UTC

Chamomile helps my stomach when it’s oogy, I do know that. Yes, ginger and peppermint are better for that for some people, but sometimes they are a bit too pungent. When I had surgery I was not able to go home from it until I had chamomile tea, because the anaesthesia made my stomach do backflips. Thank goodness they had some.


Make a comment





Edit | Back

Mythbusting: Herbal Teas

Alex doesn’t believe that Camomile, Ginkgo or Valarian herbal teas work. So he’s testing them, with the aid of Guitar Hero, World of Warcraft, and a LOT of tea…

Length: 12 min

Links:

Credits:

Presented by Alex
Assisted by Hugh

Petunia played by Lizzie Cass-Maran

Camerawork and Direction by Hugh Hancock

Editing, Motion Graphics and Sound by Hugh Hancock

Images by

Kanko @ Flickr
Roshan Rao @ Flickr
Ayelie (Editor at Large) @ Flickr

Others mostly from Wikipedia

Executive Producer: Hugh Hancock

License: Released under Creative Commons BY-SA-NC